Wayne Gebhardt, Broker/Owner of Homesaver Real Estate in Stuart, FL

By Wayne Gebhardt, Broker/Owner, Homesaver Real Estate, Stuart, FL. Last updated November 18, 2026.

The short answer: you usually do not need to pay off your student loans before buying a home. The two things that decide it are your student loan interest rate and how much cash you will have left after closing. Paying off a low-rate loan early can leave you with too little cushion for your first year as a homeowner.

A buyer on Reddit recently laid out a situation I see often, so let's use it as the example.

The example

  • $100,000 salary, great credit, no other debt
  • About $100,000 saved, plus a separate retirement account
  • $29,000 left on student loans, paying $500 a month (about twice the minimum)
  • Looking at homes around $250,000 with a mortgage rate around 6.2%
  • Rent is $1,150; a home would cost about $2,400 a month

Test 1: Compare the interest rates

Paying off debt is a guaranteed return equal to its interest rate.

  • If your student loan rate is higher than your mortgage rate, paying it down is a strong move.
  • If it is well below your mortgage rate, paying it off early mostly turns liquid cash into money you cannot get back out. As a new homeowner, cash is what protects you.

Test 2: How much cash is left after closing?

Keep the loans, keep payingPay the loans off first
Savings to start$100,000$71,000
20% down on $250,000$50,000$50,000
Closing costs (estimate, about 3%)$7,500$7,500
Cash left after closingAbout $42,500About $13,500

That leftover cash has to cover moving, furniture, an emergency fund and the repairs that always show up in the first year: an AC service call, a water heater, a roof leak. About $13,500 is thin for that. About $42,500 is comfortable.

Test 3: Can you live with the payment?

On a $100,000 salary, gross income is about $8,333 a month. A $2,400 housing payment plus a $250 minimum student loan payment is about 32% of that. Most lenders will approve it easily. The better question is whether the payment fits your budget with room to keep saving.

Also check where the $2,400 comes from. With 20% down at 6.2%, principal and interest on a $200,000 loan is about $1,225 a month. The rest is property taxes, homeowners insurance and any HOA dues. In Florida, insurance and taxes can be a big share of the payment, so get real quotes on the homes you are looking at.

A middle path that often works best

  1. Buy with your planned down payment and keep a solid emergency fund.
  2. Live in the home a few months and learn your real costs.
  3. Then go back to paying extra on the student loans.

If your student loan rate is high, you can also do it the other way: pay off part of the balance now, as long as you still close with a healthy cushion.

How lenders see your student loans

Lenders count a monthly student loan payment in your debt-to-income ratio, and the rules differ by loan type, especially for $0 income-driven payments. I explain the differences in Does Student Loan Debt Stop You From Buying a House?

Frequently asked questions

Will paying off my student loans raise my credit score?
Not by much, and sometimes it dips slightly when an account closes. On-time payment history matters more.

Is 20% down required?
No. Many conventional loans allow much less, with mortgage insurance. Putting less down keeps more cash in the bank, but raises the monthly payment.

How big should my emergency fund be after I buy?
Many planners suggest three to six months of expenses, plus money set aside for home repairs each year.

This article is general information, not financial, tax or lending advice. Wayne Gebhardt is a real estate broker, not a financial advisor or loan officer. Talk with a licensed lender and a financial professional about your situation.

Thinking about buying your first home on the Treasure Coast?

I can help you see what homes in your price range really cost each month, including Florida insurance and taxes, before you decide.

Call or text Wayne at 772-600-4836 or email Wayne@Homesaverrealestate.com.

Wayne Gebhardt, Broker, Homesaver Real Estate LLC, 395 SW Sally Way, Stuart, FL 34997