Florida gets a lot of attention from real estate investors, and the Treasure Coast is no exception. Port St. Lucie, Stuart and Fort Pierce offer steady rental demand, a coastal lifestyle and prices that are often lower than in Palm Beach County to the south. But the numbers that decide whether an investment works here are not always the ones in the headlines.

I'm Wayne Gebhardt, a licensed broker with Homesaver Real Estate LLC in Stuart. Here is what I tell investors who are new to the area.

Pick your strategy before you pick a city

Most investors start by asking which city is best. A better first question is what you want the property to do for you.

  • Long-term rentals: These have been the steadiest play on the Treasure Coast. Port St. Lucie in particular has year-round renter demand. Single-family homes outside flood zones with newer roofs tend to rent and insure most easily.
  • Vacation or short-term rentals: These can work, but rules vary a lot by city, county and HOA. Many communities limit or prohibit short-term leases. Check the rules before you make an offer, not after.
  • Long-term appreciation: Waterfront and coastal areas with limited land have generally held value well, but expect thinner cash flow because of higher prices, taxes and insurance.

Run your property taxes at investor rates

This is the most common mistake I see. Florida's homestead exemption only applies to your primary residence. A rental or second home does not get it, so the seller's tax bill is often much lower than what you will pay.

Amendment 3, which Florida voters approved on November 3, 2026, raises the homestead exemption for primary homes, but that benefit does not extend to investment property. One change does help investors: starting January 1, 2027, the cap on yearly assessment increases for non-homestead property drops from 10% to 5% for non-school taxes. That makes future tax bills on rentals and second homes more predictable.

When you analyze a property, estimate taxes based on your purchase price at the full non-homestead rate. Your county property appraiser's website has tax estimators that help.

Get insurance quotes before you make an offer

Insurance remains one of the biggest costs of owning in Florida. The good news is that the market has been improving, with several carriers filing for rate decreases in 2026. Still, premiums can vary by thousands of dollars depending on:

  • Roof age and type
  • Wind mitigation features such as hurricane shutters, impact windows and roof straps
  • Flood zone and elevation
  • Year built and the condition of electrical and plumbing systems

Ask for a wind mitigation report and a four-point inspection early, and get real quotes during your inspection period. A home that looks like a great deal can stop working once the insurance quote comes in.

Be careful with older condos

After the Surfside collapse, Florida passed laws requiring milestone structural inspections and fully funded reserves for many older condo buildings. In some buildings, that has led to large special assessments and higher monthly dues.

Before buying a condo as an investment, read the reserve study, the most recent milestone inspection if one is required, the budget and the last year of board meeting minutes. Also check the association's rental rules. Many condos limit how soon you can rent after buying, how often you can lease, or the minimum lease length.

Do not forget flood risk

Recent heavy rain and flooding in parts of St. Lucie County are a reminder that elevation and drainage matter. Check the flood zone, ask the seller about past flooding, and get a flood insurance quote even if the property is not in a required flood zone. Florida flood policies often have a waiting period before coverage starts, so do not leave it until closing week.

Frequently asked questions

Can an investor get the Florida homestead exemption?

No. Homestead is only for your permanent primary residence. Rentals and second homes pay non-homestead rates.

What does Amendment 3 change for rental property owners?

Starting January 1, 2027, the yearly cap on assessment increases for non-homestead property drops from 10% to 5% for non-school taxes. It does not give rentals the larger homestead exemption.

Are short-term rentals allowed on the Treasure Coast?

It depends on the city, county and especially the HOA or condo association. Always read the governing documents before you buy.

Should I talk to a CPA before investing?

Yes. This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. A CPA can explain how the tax changes and depreciation affect your situation.

Thinking about an investment property on the Treasure Coast?

I'm happy to help you run the numbers on a specific property, including real tax and insurance estimates, before you commit. Call or text Wayne Gebhardt at 772-600-4836 or email Wayne@Homesaverrealestate.com.

Homesaver Real Estate LLC, 395 SW Sally Way, Stuart, FL 34997.